Diana Nyad Fact Check: First Pro Race

Inflate 4 hours to 37 and 30 entrants to 444. Chill 66-degree water to 48, and reduce 10th place to 3rd. Season with atrocious sportsmanship. Voilà — Nyad’s unstable tales of her first professional race.

Diana Wins: The true story of Diana Nyad’s first pro race.

. . .

In July 1970, Diana Nyad headed to Hamilton, Ontario, for her first professional open water race, the 10-mile Labbat’s International Championship. Swimming under ideal conditions — little wind, a warm sun coaxing the water temperature into the mid-60s — Nyad set a women’s record of 4:23. She finished 10th overall out of a field of 30, beating five-time world champion Judith de Nijs by 12 minutes. A great debut by any measure.

But it has never been enough for Diana.

. . .

“It was a long day — 37 hours and 38 minutes across Lake Ontario.”

Beachbody 2014 (23:27)

“The lake was 48 degrees. . . I finished third among the 444 that day.”

K8 East (48° | third of 444)

. . .

In 1978, Nyad reported that “the water temperature was 62 degrees, and out of sixty professional swimmers, I finished tenth” (Other Shores, p. 31).

By 1997, the field had grown to over 200. Twelve years later, Nyad claimed that 444 had lined up at Hamilton to start the race.

Nyad also inflates her time; a four-hour swim is hardly epic. So, in a May 2020 presentation, Nyad balloons her 4:23 to over 18 hours. In her 2014 Beachbody program, Nyad reported winning at Hamilton by swimming across the lake — rather than 20 times around a half-mile course near the beach — in 37 hours and 38 minutes.

Ideal conditions also fail the epicness test, so she drops the water temperature — variously reported in the press between 64 and 66 — down to 48. Neither Nyad nor most of the other entrants could tolerate that for 4 hours. None could survive it for 18 or 37.

Chart adapted from the Transportation Safety Board of Canada’s report on the sinking of the fishing boat “NADINE.”

After messing with distance, time, and temperature, Nyad, who once said, “I don’t bad mouth other swimmers,” bad-mouths Judith de Nijs. Nyad attacks de Nijs and other female athletes so often, in fact, that the bad-mouthing gets its own page. Suffice it to say here that Judith de Nijs won pro marathon swimming’s World Championship six times to Nyad’s once (see “When is a world champion not a world champion?”). And Diana Nyad can’t tolerate anyone being perceived as better than Diana Nyad. So, to make herself feel better, she crouches behind a façade of superiority and takes potshots at one of history’s best professional marathon swimmers.

World Professional Marathon Swimming Federation Women’s World Champions through 1975
1964	Judith de Nijs
1965	Judith de Nijs
1966	Judith de Nijs
1967	Judith de Nijs
1968	Judith de Nijs
1969	Patti Thompson (Canada)
1970	Judith de Nijs
1971	Shadia El Rageb (Egypt)
1972	Shadia El Rageb
1973	Corrie Dixon Ebbelaar (The Netherlands)
1974	Diana Nyad
1975	Angela Marchetti (Argentina)
Note: Nyad left the tour after 1975.
Chart adapted from Open Water Boek 2015, from the Royal Netherland Swimming Association (KNZB), edited by (and with thanks to) Richard Broer.

First Pro Race (1970)