NyadFactCheck

The Truth About Diana Nyad

 

 

Nyad vs. Nyad Summaries

Diana Nyad often contradicts herself from one version of a story to another. The list below links to summaries of these contradictions.

 

Swimming-related

  • Age of Onset

    Diana began swimming competitively when she was 12 — and 11, 10, 9, 8, and 7.

  • Cuba

    We may never know what happened in the Florida Straits on August 31–September 2, 2013. But whatever it was, it likely didn't involve a legitimate Cuba–Florida crossing. This document summarizes the reasons why.

  • Discovering Cuba

    Nowadays, Nyad says she discovered Cuba when she was nine and her mom pointed to it from the beach. That's a great story that she invented after she realized it sounded better than the truth.

  • First Pro

    Nyad's first professional race has become her most protean undertaking. Thirty, 60, 200 or 444 started the race. Water temperature was 66 or 48. The distance was 10 or 40 miles. Nyad finished third or tenth in four hours and 23 minutes, 18 hours and 20 minutes, or 37 hours and 38 minutes. Etc.

  • First Pro (with excerpts)

    This version includes excerpts of Nyad's First Pro stories.

  • Manhattan

    Diana Nyad was the seventh woman to swim around Manhattan Island. Then she made herself the first. For a short time, she gave up first. And then she made herself first again.

  • Marathon Swimming Origin Story

    When Nyad was 20 years old, she learned about the sport of marathon swimming from Buck Dawson of the International Swimming Hall of Fame. She also says she learned about the sport from a graduate school friend when she was 24. And 29.

  • Olympic Trials

    Nyad says she competed at the trials. She also says she didn't qualify for the trials.

  • Sick

    When she was 16, Nyad got sick and spent between two weeks and "years" recuperating. She says that's why she didn't reach the Olympics. She also says it wasn't.

  • Lake Ontario

    Nyad's gives conflicting statements about her Lake Ontario solo, and she lied about it to Gertrude Ederle.

 

Other

  • Academic Freedom

    Nyad never earned a graduate degree, but that hasn't stopped her from saying she has a master's or a PhD.

  • Coming Out

    The Guardian's Carole Cadwalladr once wrote that Nyad "came out as gay in her early 20s, and she's never had any issues about it or tried in any way to hide it." This summary shows Nyad hiding it until at least her late 40s.

  • Fifth-Grade Essay

    Beginning in the 1970s, Nyad started talking about an essay in which, as a ten-year-old, she exhorted herself to wring the most from every moment. As usual, some versions differ significantly from others. Her grandparents' ages prove particularly slippery. (This story eventually metamorphoses into her sixth-grade valediction story. See this timeline.)

  • Holocaust Story

    Nyad tells a story about a girl that the Nazis forced into sexual slavery during the Holocaust. This document summarizes the differences between versions that betray the tale's fraudulence. The document also addresses a fraudulent WWII-related story Nyad told about her family.

  • Lying

    Some of Nyad's lies about lying.

  • Nyad on Film

    Statements Nyad made about a Nyad movie in the years before Nyad, the movie.

  • Stepfather Claims

    When did Diana learn that Aristotle Z. Nyad was her stepfather? Not when she says she did.