NyadFactCheck
The Truth About Diana Nyad
This page links mainly to files included in WOWSA’s Diana Nyad Cuba-Florida Swim 2013 Report. Exceptions:
GPS data
For explanations, see the “GPS Trackers” section of the report.
Logs
McVeigh 1. original 2. typed transcription 3. online (archived) |
Hinkle 1. original 2. typed transcription 3. online (archived) |
Bartlett 1. Log (same as above) 2. Journal (unfinished) |
Combined
1. WOWSA — combines Hinkle, McVeigh, and Bartlett logs
2. McCarley — combines Hinkle and McVeigh logs
Version Differences In the Observer Journals
Some entries appear in all three versions of an observer’s log, some in two, and some in only
one. This spreadsheet
tracks the differences between versions.
(NOTE: The WOWSA report includes a cursory look at the “Differences in Handwritten and Typed Logs.” You can find it in the “Handwritten Observer Logs” section.)
Rules
5 Aug 2011
“Here are the official rules of the swim!” (archived here) Repost of Steven Munatones’ “Official Finish Of An Open Water Swim.” This is the only “set” of rules Nyad followed.
|
~2013
WOWSA rules for marathon and channel swims
|
12 Aug 2019
WOWSA’s “Rules Governing Swims Across Strait of Florida” Part of a 3-page document Steven Munatones wrote in support of South African swimmer Cameron Bellamy’s proposed Cuba–Florida attempt. Note that August 12, 2019, is two or three days before Steven Munatones doctored Diana Nyad’s Openwaterpedia entry to illegitimately ratify her crossing.
|
| 24 Aug 2019
“WOWSA Rules Governing Swims Across Strait of Florida” (reformatted version) From Steven Munatones’ proposed article about Florida Strait rules.
|
date unknown
“Florida Straits Open Water Swimming Association” rules
(reformatted
version) |
Other Rule-Related Data
13 May 2012
Ned Denison proposes governing organization for swims in the Florida Straits (reformatted version)
28 Aug 2013
Observer guidelines for “THE GREATEST SWIM IN THE HISTORY OF MANKIND”
28 Aug 2013
Nyad asks Voyager Drivers to double as observers
. . . and follow Steven’s revised “not every hour” rules.
31 Aug–2 Sep 2013
Rules in the observer logs — When either of the two observers mentioned a rule in their logs, it was almost always some version of, “No touching at the finish!”
“Diana’s Rules” (from Janet Hinkle’s original log)
20 Nov 2014
Steven Munatones creates FSOWSA
Munatones creates the Florida Straits Open Water Swimming Association via an Openwaterpedia entry.
Images, Audio, and Video
Day 1 slide show - Vimeo | archived (38MB) (268MB)
Day 2 slide show - Vimeo | archived (44MB) (302MB)
Day 3 slide show - Vimeo | archived (37MB) (325MB)
Day 3 - around 6 am on 2 Sep 2013 (via John McCumber’s GoPro)
Day 3 - Angel Yanagihara compilation, including speech
Details from above videos
*Nyad to Time magazine (my emphasis):
“I was admittedly touched. After much effort in pulling that stinger suit over wet skin by myself, I could not get the final inch of zipping it at the back of the neck. A shark diver would come around the back and pull the zipper up. He did not hold me afloat to do the zipping.”
Other Yanagihara videos:
Before crossing:
Night
20130901 iphone 0668 18th wind
Little fish
Night
“The Last and Longest Night: John Bartlett Our Navigator Through the Storm” lo-res | hi-res
Compilation from Nyad’s YouTube channel.
Nyad’s YouTube page had 28 videos as of 2 Mar 2025.
On May 23, 2020, Nyad said, “I’ve got a million series of videos on YouTube” (re:invention-virtual-chat, 39:17, clip). As of 30 Sep 2020, Nyad’s YouTube channel was empty.
Crew photo compilation - images by Deanne Scott
Speech on September 2, 2013 at 10:41 a.m.
Teleconference, 10 Sep 2013 - Commercial footage via Pond5
Earlier Cuba-Florida attempt clips
Final Morning
“6:00 AM - 9 AM - 7:00 AM Cruiseship” (images by Deanne Scott)
“8:44 AM Swimming” (video by Deanne Scott)
“Day 3 - 8:14 AM - Finish” (images by Dawn Blomgren)
John Bartlett explains readings and navigation
Video taken September 1, 2013 at 6:25 PM explaining readings and navigation. Video credit Alex De Cordoba.
John Bartlett’s Documents
“Navigator’s Log—John Bartlett” (archived) appeared on Diana Nyad’s blog on September 13, 2013. At first, the post linked to six documents, which subsequently disappeared. Through the magic of the Internet Archive Wayback Machine, however, we can still nab ’em:
|
|
||||
|
Readings of Gulf Stream |
Positions Plot Sheet (ostensibly plotted during crossing, but current readings don’t change from previous chart) |
Pre-Navigation Plot Sheet (with actual positions added after crossing) |
Crew Statements
The report includes 31 statements. All but four were publicly available before the investigation began.
|
Listing in report |
Source |
|
NEW (dated 25 Jul 2022) |
|
|
NEW (undated) |
|
|
NEW (undated) |
|
|
NEW(dated 25 Jul 2022) |
|
|
ISHOF packet
|
|
|
User godzillaboat in the Marathon Swimmers Forum’s “110 miles, 53 hours . . .” discussion. |
|
|
personal website (archived) |
|
|
University of Nevada, Reno, School of Medicine (archived) |
|
|
Cal Bucci – Shark Team |
no statement |
|
Jason Tiller – Shark Team |
" |
|
Captain Dave Magnone – Captain |
" |
|
Beverly Magnone – Owner |
" |
|
Taylor Cline – Transport |
" |
|
Dave Whidden – Voyager Driver |
" |
|
“Diver” Judy Montague – Media |
" |
|
Dawn Blomgren – Official Photographer |
" |
|
Alex De Cordoba – Social Media |
" |
|
John Kot – MD |
" |
|
Vanessa Linsley – Marine ops-Ground ops |
" |
|
Cindy DeRocher – Ground ops |
" |
|
Cathy Ebert – Ops Press |
" |
Above: Diana Nyad’s crew. Image originally via Nyad’s 26 September 2013 blog post, “Cuba: 3 Weeks Later.” Photographer: Dawn Blomgren.
The Support Team
In the back of Find a Way, Diana lists the members of her “Xtreme Dream Team.” She breaks the list into sections: “Handlers,” “Kayakers,” “Shark divers,” etc. The largest section by far is “The Support Team.” This spreadsheet includes information about the PR reps, lawyers, agents and others in that section and the remaining two media-related categories.
Data Analyses
From the WOWSA report:
From my blog post “Diana Nyad Could Not Have Completed A Legitimate Crossing From Cuba To Florida, And Here’s Why”:
Analyses of all available data at time of inquiry